Melissa and Doug vs Banwood: which affiliate program pays better?
Two toys & games programs ranked next to each other on Affiliate Graph, compared on the public terms their networks list. Melissa and Doug lists the higher top commission (2.4%–15% against 2%–8%). Neither program publishes a cookie window in its network listing. They share 2 networks (Digidip, Flexoffers), so one publisher account can carry both. Both hold an Affiliate Graph Rank score of 94/100 in Toys & Games.
| Term |  Melissa and Doug |  Banwood |
|---|---|---|
| Listed commission | 2.4%–15% | 2%–8% |
| Cookie window | Not published | Not published |
| Networks | 7: Connexity, Digidip, Flexoffers, Loyalize, Rakuten, Skimlinks, Sovrn | 3: Digidip, Flexoffers, Impact |
| Direct networks | Rakuten | Impact |
| Rank score | 94/100 | 94/100 |
| Rank basis | observed commission | observed commission |
| Brand size | Very large | Mid-size |
| Categories | Toys & Games, Gifts, Education, Home & Garden | Sports & Outdoors, Baby & Toddler, Toys & Games, Accessories |
| Markets | US, PR | US, EU, UK, DE, ES, FR, IT, RO |
| Status | Active | Active |
Choose Melissa and Doug for
- the higher listed commission (2.4%–15%)
- more ways to join (7 networks)
Choose Banwood for
Fit with your audience: on the listed terms Melissa and Doug has the edge, and Banwood is the better choice where its products match what you cover.
Banwood program detailsWhere to join
Both programs are listed on Digidip, Flexoffers. Melissa and Doug is also on Connexity, Loyalize, Rakuten, Skimlinks, Sovrn. Banwood is also on Impact.
Compared on listed program terms from the networks' public listings. Rates and cookies change; confirm current terms on the network before applying. The rank score is a position among tracked US and UK brands, indexed 0 to 100; the underlying figures are not published. Methodology · Data updated Oct 23, 2026.